@LouisIngenthron @emilymbender No, that's exactly what I said. ChatGPT produces something. You privately forward it to me. I forward it to a big list. Under your theory, you then become liable for ChatGPT's speech. I, the forwarder, am not.

@LouisIngenthron @emilymbender Note also that the plain statutory language of CDA 230 doesn't contain any requirement for a responsible first party. I am immunized for "any information provided by another information content provider", which ChatGPT might reasonably be deemed to be.